Chloe Liese’s The Wilmot Sisters series has become a fan-favorite in contemporary romance, thanks to its heartfelt characters, authentic representation, and deliciously swoony romance arcs. The series began with Two Wrongs Make a Right, a Shakespearean-inspired tale where opposites attract through a fake-dating trope. It was followed by Better Hate than Never, a steamy retelling of The Taming of the Shrew layered with themes of emotional growth and healing.
Now, in Once Smitten, Twice Shy, Liese turns to Twelfth Night for inspiration, delivering an enchanting and tender romance that pairs Juliet, the hopeless romantic grappling with heartbreak, with Will, the emotionally guarded distillery heir. This third book not only stands tall on its own but adds new depth to the series, weaving the stories of the Wilmot sisters into a resonant, interconnected narrative.
Plot Summary: A Tale of Second Chances and Reluctant Romance
Juliet Wilmot is no stranger to love—or heartbreak. After ending an emotionally abusive relationship, she has sworn off romance and buried her once-unshakable optimism. Seeking solace in a Scottish pub, she meets the enigmatic Will Orsino, a striking red-haired American grappling with his own scars. Their fleeting connection ignites a spark, but both walk away, assuming their paths will never cross again.
Months later, fate intervenes, reuniting Juliet and Will under unexpected circumstances. Will, a shy and reserved man whose family business demands that he marry, proposes a unique arrangement: Juliet helps him practice romance to prepare for a marriage of convenience. In return, Will becomes her “training wheels” for reentering the dating world after her hiatus.
What begins as a lighthearted and practical partnership evolves into something much deeper. Through stolen glances, gentle touches, and unspoken longing, their “practice” reveals their undeniable chemistry. But Juliet and Will must confront their fears of vulnerability and their reluctance to trust before they can embrace the possibility of a true happily-ever-after.
Character Analysis: Layers of Humanity
Juliet Wilmot:
Juliet is a refreshing take on a neurodivergent and chronically ill protagonist, depicted with honesty and sensitivity. Her battle with mixed connective tissue disease and the emotional aftermath of abuse make her journey toward self-acceptance both heart-wrenching and triumphant. Liese’s portrayal of Juliet’s resilience and humor—often accompanied by her meddling but loving sisters—adds depth to her character.
Will Orsino:
Will, a self-described introvert and awkward flirt, is one of Liese’s most nuanced male leads. His struggles with social anxiety, sensory issues, and his neurodivergence create a relatable and empathetic portrayal of someone learning to embrace vulnerability. The slow unraveling of Will’s emotional walls is beautifully executed, making him both endearing and unforgettable.
Writing Style: Soulful and Relatable
Liese’s writing is as warm and cozy as a rainy-day blanket. Her prose is fluid and packed with sensory details, allowing readers to feel the hum of a busy pub, the sharp ache of heartbreak, and the sweetness of a shared smile. The dialogue sparkles with wit, humor, and authenticity, especially during moments of banter between Juliet and Will. Moreover, the alternating perspectives immerse readers in both characters’ emotional landscapes, making their love story deeply personal.
Themes Explored: Beyond Romance
- Healing and Growth: Juliet and Will’s journeys emphasize the importance of patience and self-compassion when healing from past wounds. Their mutual understanding and encouragement make their love story a safe haven for readers who may see themselves in their struggles.
- Representation Matters: Chloe Liese’s commitment to authentic representation shines through. From neurodivergence to chronic illness, she crafts characters who are richly complex without reducing them to their diagnoses.
- Family Bonds: The Wilmot sisters play a pivotal role, offering humor, heart, and unconditional support. Their presence not only grounds the story but also enriches it with subplots that feel as engaging as the central romance.
Strengths of the Novel
- Slow-Burn Chemistry: Juliet and Will’s romance builds with a delicate balance of tension and release, making each tender moment electric.
- Authenticity in Representation: The book’s portrayal of autism, sensory sensitivities, and chronic illness is handled with grace and care, making it relatable and uplifting.
- Shakespearean Influence: As a reimagining of Twelfth Night, the story’s nods to mistaken identities and fate align seamlessly with the original, while adding a modern twist.
Critiques: A Solid Four-Star Read
While Once Smitten, Twice Shy excels in its tender romance and character-driven narrative, there are moments where pacing slows. Some internal monologues, though introspective and heartfelt, feel repetitive and detract from the momentum of the romance. Additionally, readers who prefer external conflict may find the stakes in this story too subdued.
The Wilmot Sisters: A Series Overview
- Two Wrongs Make a Right: Bea and Jamie’s enemies-to-lovers fake-dating trope is charming and fiery, packed with snappy banter.
- Better Hate than Never: Kate and Christopher’s love story is a tempestuous slow burn that tackles neurodivergence and emotional communication.
- Once Smitten, Twice Shy: Juliet and Will’s story combines sweet and steamy moments with an underlying message of hope and healing.
Each book stands alone but is enriched by the recurring themes of family, Shakespearean inspiration, and self-discovery.
Recommendation: For Fans of Thoughtful Romance
Readers who loved The Kiss Quotient by Helen Hoang or Get a Life, Chloe Brown by Talia Hibbert will find much to admire in Once Smitten, Twice Shy. Both books share similar themes of inclusivity, humor, and the transformative power of love.
Additionally, fans of the Wilmot sisters will appreciate how this book brings their journeys full circle, making it a satisfying conclusion to the series.
Personal Take: Why This Story Resonates
What makes Once Smitten, Twice Shy extraordinary is its focus on real, flawed individuals finding love not despite their struggles, but because of their authenticity. As someone who cherishes romance novels for their escapism and emotional catharsis, I found this story profoundly uplifting. Juliet and Will’s dynamic—filled with humor, quiet vulnerability, and a slow dance toward trust—is one I’ll carry with me.
Conclusion: A Story to Savor
Chloe Liese’s Once Smitten, Twice Shy is a testament to her storytelling prowess, blending Shakespearean whimsy with heartfelt realism. This book is not just a romance—it’s a celebration of hope, courage, and finding joy in life’s imperfections. For readers looking for a story that feels like a warm hug, this is one to add to your bookshelf.
