There’s something irresistible about a romance between two people who are fundamentally different yet somehow perfectly suited for each other. In Never Planned on You, Lindsay Hameroff crafts a delightful second-chance romance between a spontaneous, passionate woman who embraces life’s adventures and a buttoned-up British man who plans everything meticulously. Their chemistry is instant, their connection undeniable, and watching them navigate the complications that arise makes for an engaging, heartwarming read.
Following the success of her debut novel Till There Was You, Hameroff returns with another romantic comedy featuring relatable characters, witty dialogue, and the kind of family dynamics that will have you nodding in recognition. Set primarily in Baltimore, this novel expertly balances laugh-out-loud moments with genuine emotional depth, creating a story that’s as touching as it is entertaining.
A Match Inked in Fate
Ali Rubin is a free spirit who follows her passions without hesitation—whether that means changing careers, pursuing culinary adventures, or getting a tattoo with a stranger in London. After working as a teacher and then a chef in New York City, she’s returned to her hometown of Baltimore to pursue yet another career path as a wedding planner. Her family sees her as flighty and unreliable, but Ali simply wants to find fulfillment and prove that she can succeed on her own terms.
Graham Wyler is Ali’s opposite in nearly every way. Responsible, cautious, and perpetually concerned with others’ expectations, he lives his life by carefully calculated decisions. When Ali and Graham first meet during her semester abroad in London, their one impulsive night together results in matching tattoos—half-unicorn, half-pig creatures that are equal parts adorable and horrifying—and a memorable hook-up they never expected to revisit.
Eight years later, fate brings them back together in Baltimore, where their chemistry reignites instantly. But there’s a complication: Graham is engaged to be married at the historic Black-Eyed Susan hotel, which belongs to his grandmother. And Ali has been assigned to plan the wedding, with a full-time job hanging in the balance if she succeeds.
The Complications of Convenience
What elevates this romance beyond a typical forbidden love story is the revelation that Graham’s engagement to Claire is actually a marriage of convenience. Claire needs a green card to continue her comedy writing career, and Graham, ever the people-pleaser, has agreed to help her. Adding to the stakes, Graham hopes the wedding will generate publicity to save his grandmother’s struggling hotel.
As Ali and Graham find themselves increasingly drawn to each other, they must navigate professional boundaries, family expectations, and their own fears about what it means to follow your heart. Their journey is complicated, messy, and beautifully authentic.
Strengths That Shine
- Truly Engaging Characters: Hameroff excels at creating characters who feel like real people you might know. Ali is wonderfully flawed—impulsive and sometimes defensive, but also creative, passionate, and deeply caring. Graham’s cautiousness stems from genuine love for his family and a desire to avoid disappointing anyone. The supporting cast shines just as brightly, particularly:
- Claire, Graham’s fake fiancée, whose vibrant personality and comedic timing make her instantly lovable
- Ali’s grandmother “Bubbie,” with her unfiltered commentary and matchmaking ambitions
- Ali’s sister Sarah, whose perfect-on-the-outside life hides vulnerabilities that create an authentic sibling dynamic
- Family Dynamics: The portrayal of Jewish family life is both specific and universal. From Friday night Shabbat dinners to Bar Mitzvah celebrations, Hameroff depicts these traditions with authenticity and warmth. The sometimes overbearing but always loving relationship between Ali and her family will resonate with readers from all backgrounds.
- Baltimore Setting: The author brings her hometown to life with affectionate details—from the iconic snowball stands to neighborhood restaurants and the charm of historic landmarks. The Black-Eyed Susan hotel becomes a character in its own right, representing both Graham’s family legacy and the couple’s shared future.
- Culinary Delights: As a former chef, Ali expresses her emotions through food, and the descriptions of her cooking provide sensory richness that enhances the storytelling. From impromptu shakshuka to comfort-food rage ragu, these culinary moments add depth to both character and plot.
Room for Improvement
While Never Planned on You is a thoroughly enjoyable read, there are a few areas where it could have been strengthened:
- Pacing Issues: The middle section drags slightly, with several scenes that could have been condensed or combined. The repeated pattern of Ali and Graham nearly giving in to their feelings, then pulling back, becomes somewhat predictable before the plot accelerates again.
- Secondary Character Development: Though Claire is wonderfully drawn, a few secondary characters feel less developed. Graham’s grandmother Trudy, in particular, shifts from being potentially antagonistic to supportive without much on-page development to explain the change.
- Conflict Resolution: The resolution of several conflicts comes rather quickly in the final chapters, particularly the situation with the hotel. After so much build-up about the financial difficulties, the turnaround feels somewhat convenient rather than earned through the characters’ actions.
Themes That Resonate
What makes this romance particularly satisfying is how it explores themes that extend beyond the love story:
- Finding Your Path: Ali’s journey to discover her true calling speaks to anyone who has struggled to find fulfillment in their career.
- Breaking Family Patterns: Both protagonists must overcome family roles that have been assigned to them—Ali as the flighty youngest child, Graham as the responsible caretaker.
- Authenticity vs. Expectations: The novel thoughtfully examines the tension between living authentically and meeting others’ expectations.
- Taking Risks: Graham and Ali must both learn that sometimes the greatest rewards come from taking chances, even when the outcome is uncertain.
Final Impressions
Never Planned on You delivers exactly what readers want from a romantic comedy—genuine laughs, emotional depth, and a satisfying happily-ever-after that feels earned. Hameroff’s writing style is conversational and witty, making it easy to become invested in these characters and their journey.
The novel’s greatest strength lies in its heart. Beyond the humor and romance, this is ultimately a story about finding the courage to pursue what truly matters, whether that’s a career that combines your passions, a relationship that challenges and supports you, or the family connections that shape who you are.
Fans of Emily Henry, Christina Lauren, and Meg Cabot will find much to love in this charming romance. With its perfect balance of humor and heart, Never Planned on You confirms Lindsay Hameroff as a rising star in the rom-com genre.
For Readers Who Enjoyed…
If you enjoyed Never Planned on You, you might also like:
- The Unhoneymooners by Christina Lauren (for its fake relationship dynamics)
- Beach Read by Emily Henry (for its emotional depth beneath the rom-com surface)
- Book Lovers by Emily Henry (for its family dynamics and career-focused protagonist)
- The Wedding People by Alison Espach (for its wedding-adjacent romance)
- Till There Was You by Lindsay Hameroff (the author’s equally charming debut novel)
Whether you’re a devoted rom-com reader or simply looking for a heartwarming story about love, family, and finding your place in the world, Never Planned on You delivers a reading experience as satisfying as Ali’s homemade shakshuka—warm, comforting, and leaving you wanting just one more taste.
