Holmes Is Missing by James Patterson and Brian Sitts

Holmes Is Missing by James Patterson and Brian Sitts

A masterful blend of contemporary suspense and legendary detective heritage that both honors and reinvents its iconic namesakes

"Holmes Is Missing" successfully builds on its predecessor while charting new territory. Despite some minor flaws, it remains a compelling addition to the contemporary detective genre, offering both entertainment and emotional depth. The novel sets up intriguing possibilities for future installments while delivering a satisfying story in its own right.
  • Publisher: Little, Brown and Company
  • Genre: Mystery Thriller
  • First Publication: 2025
  • Language: English
  • Series: Holmes, Margaret & Poe Book #2
  • Previous Book: Holmes, Margaret & Poe

In “Holmes Is Missing,” the second installment of Patterson and Sitts’ innovative Holmes, Marple & Poe series, readers are treated to an intricate tapestry of mysteries that weaves together multiple compelling storylines. Following the success of their first book “Holmes, Marple & Poe,” this new entry raises the stakes while delving deeper into the complex relationships between its distinctive lead characters.

The Plot

Set in contemporary Brooklyn, the story opens with a chilling crisis: six newborns have vanished from St. Michael’s Hospital’s maternity ward. Adding to the urgency, the brilliant but troubled Brendan Holmes is absent when his partners need him most, having checked himself into rehab to battle his heroin addiction. As Margaret Marple and Auguste Poe race to solve the kidnappings, they must also contend with a parallel case involving missing schoolchildren and a series of methodically planned “accidental” deaths spanning decades.

Character Development

The authors excel at crafting multidimensional characters whose personal struggles enrich rather than overshadow the central mysteries. Margaret Marple shines as the heart of the agency, combining shrewd observation with genuine empathy. Auguste Poe’s complex relationship with Detective Helene Grey adds emotional depth to his character, especially as they navigate unexpected news about their future together.

Brendan Holmes’ journey through addiction and recovery is particularly well-handled, avoiding both glamorization and oversimplification of his struggles. His eventual return to the agency brings fresh complications as he grapples with both professional and personal revelations.

Writing Style and Pacing

Patterson and Sitts maintain a brisk pace throughout, skillfully juggling multiple plot threads without losing momentum. The prose is crisp and efficient, with moments of genuine wit punctuating the tension. While some readers might find the frequent perspective shifts initially challenging, they ultimately serve to create a more complete picture of the interwoven mysteries.

Strengths

  • Masterful integration of personal drama with procedural elements
  • Rich character development that builds on the foundation established in the first book
  • Clever modernization of classic detective fiction tropes
  • Satisfying balance of action and deduction
  • Strong emotional resonance in character relationships

Areas for Improvement

  • Some plot resolutions feel rushed in the final chapters
  • Certain secondary characters could benefit from further development
  • The connection between parallel storylines occasionally feels forced
  • A few dramatic moments risk straining credibility

Thematic Depth

The novel explores compelling themes including:

Series Context

While “Holmes Is Missing” builds on the foundation laid in the first book, it remains accessible to new readers. That said, familiarity with the original “Holmes, Marple & Poe” enhances appreciation of the character development and relationship dynamics.

Final Verdict

“Holmes Is Missing” successfully expands the series’ scope while maintaining its core appeal. The novel proves that Patterson and Sitts can sustain the creative premise of their detective trio while adding layers of complexity to both the mysteries and the characters’ personal lives.

Recommendation

This book will particularly appeal to:

  • Fans of contemporary detective fiction
  • Readers who enjoy complex character dynamics
  • Admirers of classic detective stories looking for a fresh take
  • Those who appreciate mysteries with multiple layers and storylines

Comparison to Similar Works

While the series pays homage to its literary predecessors, it stands distinct from other contemporary detective series. Unlike many modern crime novels that lean heavily on either procedure or action, this series maintains a careful balance between intellectual puzzle-solving and physical danger.

Impact and Relevance

The book’s exploration of contemporary issues within a classic detective framework makes it particularly relevant to modern readers. Its treatment of addiction, institutional corruption, and complex moral choices resonates with current social discussions while maintaining its entertainment value.

Author Background and Style

James Patterson’s trademark fast-paced storytelling meshes well with Brian Sitts’ attention to character detail. Their collaboration produces a narrative that feels both familiar and fresh, maintaining Patterson’s accessibility while adding deeper character exploration.

Conclusion

“Holmes Is Missing” successfully builds on its predecessor while charting new territory. Despite some minor flaws, it remains a compelling addition to the contemporary detective genre, offering both entertainment and emotional depth. The novel sets up intriguing possibilities for future installments while delivering a satisfying story in its own right.

Reading Experience

Best enjoyed over several focused sessions to fully appreciate the intricacy of the plot threads, this novel rewards careful attention while maintaining enough momentum to keep readers engaged throughout. The multiple perspectives and parallel storylines create a rich reading experience that invites speculation and analysis.

This sophomore effort in the Holmes, Marple & Poe series confirms that Patterson and Sitts have created something special—a detective series that honors its classical roots while blazing its own contemporary trail.

More on this topic

Comments

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

  • Publisher: Little, Brown and Company
  • Genre: Mystery Thriller
  • First Publication: 2025
  • Language: English

Readers also enjoyed

This Is a Love Story by Jessica Soffer

In "This Is a Love Story," Jessica Soffer's second...

The Otherwhere Post by Emily J. Taylor

Dive into The Otherwhere Post by Emily J. Taylor, a mesmerizing fantasy novel where magic flows through ink, and secrets hide within enchanted script. This review explores the book’s worldbuilding, character depth, and spellbinding mystery.

Junie by Erin Crosby Eckstine

Junie by Erin Crosby Eckstine is a powerful blend of historical fiction and magical realism, following a young enslaved girl’s journey through grief, love, and defiance in the American South. Read our in-depth review.

Something in the Walls by Daisy Pearce

A chilling review of Daisy Pearce’s Something in the Walls, a folk horror novel where supernatural terror and psychological trauma intertwine in a haunted Cornish village.

Book Boyfriend by Emily Wibberley and Austin Siegemund-Broka

Book Boyfriend by Emily Wibberley & Austin Siegemund-Broka explores the line between fiction and reality in romance. A witty enemies-to-lovers novel, it dives into fandom culture while questioning what truly makes the perfect book boyfriend.

Popular stories

"Holmes Is Missing" successfully builds on its predecessor while charting new territory. Despite some minor flaws, it remains a compelling addition to the contemporary detective genre, offering both entertainment and emotional depth. The novel sets up intriguing possibilities for future installments while delivering a satisfying story in its own right.Holmes Is Missing by James Patterson and Brian Sitts