First Lie Wins by Ashley Elston

In the world of suspense thrillers, it’s rare to find a debut that hits all the right notes with such precision and flair. Ashley Elston’s “First Lie Wins” does just that, delivering a pulse-pounding narrative that will keep readers guessing until the very last page. Known for her young adult novels, Elston makes a striking entrance into the adult thriller genre with this intricate tale of identity, deception, and the dangerous games we play.

The Chameleon at the Center

At the heart of “First Lie Wins” is Evie Porter, a character so expertly crafted that you’ll find yourself simultaneously rooting for her and questioning her every move. Evie is the perfect Southern belle—charming, beautiful, and utterly devoted to her boyfriend, Ryan Sumner. She’s the kind of woman who fits seamlessly into small-town life, making friends and creating a picture-perfect existence.

There’s just one small problem: Evie Porter doesn’t exist.

Elston has created a protagonist who is as complex as she is compelling. Evie is a chameleon, slipping in and out of identities with practiced ease. She’s a con artist, a liar, and potentially something much darker. But as we delve deeper into her psyche, we discover layers of vulnerability and a yearning for authenticity that make her undeniably human.

A Web of Lies and Love

The plot of “First Lie Wins” is a masterclass in suspense writing. Elston weaves a complex web of lies, half-truths, and dangerous secrets that keep the reader constantly on edge. The central romance between Evie and Ryan is both sweet and fraught with tension. As Evie finds herself falling for her mark, the stakes rise exponentially.

Ryan Sumner, the object of Evie’s affection (and mission), is far from a simple target. Elston has crafted a love interest who is just as layered and intriguing as our protagonist. The chemistry between Evie and Ryan crackles off the page, making their developing relationship both thrilling and heartbreaking.

But it’s not just the central relationship that shines. The supporting cast is equally well-developed, from Evie’s mysterious boss Mr. Smith to the small-town characters that populate Ryan’s world. Each person feels fully realized, with their own motivations and secrets.

A Southern Gothic Twist

One of the most striking aspects of “First Lie Wins” is its setting. Elston, a Louisiana native, brings the small Southern town to vivid life. The suffocating heat, the syrupy-sweet social niceties, and the undercurrent of secrets and judgment create an atmosphere reminiscent of Southern Gothic literature.

This backdrop serves as the perfect stage for Evie’s performance, highlighting both her skill at blending in and the constant danger of exposure. The juxtaposition of Evie’s dark past with the seemingly idyllic small-town setting creates a delicious tension that permeates every page.

Pacing and Plot Twists: A Rollercoaster Ride

Elston’s background in young adult literature shines through in the pacing of “First Lie Wins.” The story moves at a breakneck speed, with reveals and twists coming at just the right moments to keep the reader engaged. Just when you think you’ve got a handle on what’s happening, Elston pulls the rug out from under you.

The structure of the novel, alternating between past and present, adds another layer of intrigue. As we learn more about Evie’s past and the events that led her to this point, the tension in the present-day narrative ratchets up. It’s a delicate balancing act, but Elston pulls it off with aplomb.

Themes of Identity and Redemption

While “First Lie Wins” is undoubtedly a thrilling read, it’s not just empty calories. Elston explores deep themes of identity, belonging, and the possibility of redemption. Can someone who has lived so many lies ever truly be themselves? Is it possible to find authenticity in a life built on deception?

Evie’s journey forces her to confront these questions, and by extension, makes the reader ponder them as well. It’s this depth that elevates “First Lie Wins” from a simple thriller to a thought-provoking exploration of the human psyche.

A Fresh Voice in the Thriller Genre

With “First Lie Wins,” Ashley Elston announces herself as a force to be reckoned with in the adult thriller genre. Her writing is crisp and evocative, with a knack for creating vivid imagery and heart-pounding tension. Fans of authors like Gillian Flynn and Karin Slaughter will find much to love here.

While this is Elston’s first foray into adult fiction, her experience as a young adult author serves her well. The novel has a freshness and energy that sets it apart from more formulaic thrillers. It’s clear that Elston has honed her craft, delivering tight plotting and well-developed characters that many seasoned thriller writers would envy.

Minor Quibbles in a Major Success

If there’s one criticism to be made of “First Lie Wins,” it’s that some readers might find the sheer number of twists and turns a bit dizzying. There are moments when keeping track of Evie’s various identities and the complex web of lies can be challenging. However, this is a minor quibble in what is otherwise a stellar debut.

Additionally, some readers might wish for a deeper exploration of certain secondary characters. While the focus on Evie and Ryan is understandable, there are a few supporting players who feel like they could have been fleshed out more fully.

The Verdict: A Must-Read Thriller

“First Lie Wins” is a triumph of suspense writing. Ashley Elston has crafted a novel that is both a page-turning thriller and a nuanced exploration of identity and morality. With its complex characters, intricate plot, and atmospheric setting, this book is sure to satisfy even the most discerning thriller fans.

Evie Porter may be a master of deception, but there’s no lie in this: “First Lie Wins” is one of the most impressive thriller debuts in recent memory. It’s a book that will keep you up late into the night, furiously turning pages to uncover the next shocking reveal.

As the first in what promises to be a successful career in adult fiction, “First Lie Wins” sets a high bar. Readers will undoubtedly be clamoring for Elston’s next offering. If this book is any indication, we’re in for a treat.

For fans of psychological thrillers, complex female protagonists, and Southern Gothic atmosphere, “First Lie Wins” is an absolute must-read. Just be prepared to question everything—and everyone—until the very last page.

Comparative Notes

While “First Lie Wins” is Ashley Elston’s debut in adult fiction, it’s worth noting her successful career in young adult literature. Her previous works include “The Rules for Disappearing” series and standalone novels like “10 Blind Dates” and “This Is Our Story.” Readers familiar with her YA work will recognize her skill at crafting engaging characters and intricate plots, now honed and adapted for an adult audience.

For those looking for similar reads, “First Lie Wins” sits comfortably alongside works by authors like Gillian Flynn (“Gone Girl,” “Sharp Objects“) and Paula Hawkins (“The Girl on the Train“). The complex female protagonist and exploration of identity bring to mind Caroline Kepnes’s “You” series, while the Southern setting and atmosphere are reminiscent of Delia Owens’s “Where the Crawdads Sing,” albeit with a much darker tone.

Fans of TV shows like “Ozark” and “Big Little Lies” will also find much to enjoy in Elston’s novel, with its blend of small-town dynamics and high-stakes deception.

In conclusion, “First Lie Wins” is a standout entry in the psychological thriller genre, marking Ashley Elston as an author to watch in the world of adult fiction. It’s a book that will linger in your mind long after you’ve turned the final page, leaving you questioning the nature of truth, identity, and the lies we tell ourselves and others.